Looking At CinemaSins' And My Criticism Of Star Wars: Episode V

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_0yLbcV3U8


6 - The droid's pod could've detected Luke’s radio from orbit if he checked in on his patrol.


12 - The opening text said the Rebels were on the run across the galaxy.


13 - Han could contact Jabba from Tatooine’s orbit and flee.


22 - When a person is close to hypothermia they can dream of being warm. If Luke was imagining being warm in a dream, that could've warmed him up via the Force.


27 - Luke mentioned that he had reached the end of the patrol route. The Wampa attacked him there. Luke fled the Wampa cave. The cave shouldn't have been far from where the Wampa attacked.


29 - It was probably only part of Luke.


35 - If Luke had known about his sister and he joined Vader...


37 - A Snow Speeder found Han. Snow Speeders could probably fly in the daytime.


4:51 (not the sin timer) - That imperial subordinate should've reported more detail about the approaching ships. He could've said 'a medium transport and 2 X-Wings are coming into our sector'.


53 - Would crashing kill them? He tortures them.


66 - It would be unrealistic for a protocol droid versed in etiquette to interrupt kissing.


67 - That’s a weird spot for the holographic projector. A viewer in Vader's position could see people walking directly behind the holograms. Screens on the Star Destroyer bridge would not have background objects showing through the image. That would be important for small radar readings.


87 - Radar only detects objects apart from its ship. So the only thing the Falcon could've done, since it didn't have stealth capability, was to attach to the Destroyer.


97 - There could’ve been an imperial ship close to Cloud City.


113 - Obi-Wan could've wanted to give Yoda company. The Dagohbah cave and raising the X-Wing out of the swamp, were lessons.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Looking At CinemaSins' And My Criticism Of Star Wars: Episode VI

I won't mention obvious... CinemaSins' video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=deMGCdOZS-Y 32 -  Luke could've Force pushed the button. (even with a wide push) 40 - A better way would've been for Luke to use the Force to untie a rope that bound his hands when he was on the end of the plank. (that 1 bandit wouldn't need to be close behind Luke when Luke was bound) Luke could then use the Force to crush the windpipes of the bandits. (he was able to do that quickly to 2 Gammoreans) Lando could help. 71 - Trees and minerals could interfere. 79 - He could've sensed Leia's helmet. 66 and 105 - Palpatine could've ordered an imperial officer to pretend to defect to the Rebels with a Lambda shuttle. 111 - The imperials could’ve wanted to interrogate them. i.e. To find out who was giving donations to the Rebels. 130 - Han put his hand on a burning spot, so he did that.
Read more

Looking At CinemaSins' And My Criticism Of Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ZDNawCEamA 10 - A better way would've been for Leia to jettison escape pods so the gun would miss the droid's escape pod. 19 - It would've been better if tracks from R2 were found. 24 - ( R2 sabotaged it in the Star Wars radio drama) 30 - It hadn’t called her a princess yet. Her capture was soon after the end of the Rogue One movie, so how would Luke know she was part of the civil war? 40 - Luke's forehead was probably hit with the center of that weapon. The movie could've shown the knockout. 46 - It wasn't known if Luke would turn evil. Luke could tell Vader about Leia if Luke became Vader’s apprentice. 48 - Perhaps the tracks disappeared via sandstorm. The movie didn't show that. Did George want to leave the audience in suspense? 49 - The stormtroopers could've radioed Vader once they spotted the SandCrawler and Vader could've told the Stormtroopers to make it look like a Sand People attack. 53 - The radio drama rev...
Read more